Scot Scoop News

Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

KOIT+radio+removes+%27Baby+It%27s+Cold+Outside%27+from+its+Christmas+playlist.
Back to Article
Back to Article

Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

KOIT radio removes 'Baby It's Cold Outside' from its Christmas playlist.

KOIT radio removes 'Baby It's Cold Outside' from its Christmas playlist.

KOIT radio removes 'Baby It's Cold Outside' from its Christmas playlist.

KOIT radio removes 'Baby It's Cold Outside' from its Christmas playlist.

Aaron Penn, Staff Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Several songs were taken off of a Bay Area radio station’s Christmas playlist this year, including Frank Loesser’s ‘Baby It’s Cold Outside.’

The song was taken off 96.5 KOIT radio station after several complaints from listeners were called in about the song’s lyrics.

The sudden action against the Christmas classic, which has appeared in both the movie ‘Elf’ and the TV show ‘Glee,’ is largely credited to the #MeToo movement, a movement giving voice to women who have experienced sexual assault.

The song follows the female lead as she insists to her friend that she must go home. The male lead then responds seductively to each excuse for her departure with, “But baby it’s cold outside,” inferring that she should stay because of the bad weather.

Many listeners felt the song went against women’s rights, with references to “date rape” found in song lyrics.

“Musically it’s very good, but the message isn’t that great. It describes females as being preyed upon by males,” Charlotte Hollier said.

Although Loesser’s song has been a popular Christmas song for decades, the complaints to this song are not without good reason. Lyrics like, “Say what’s in this drink,” “I simply must go,” and “the answer is ‘no,’” are said over and over again in a polite tone as the man protests.

Angelina Russo, a Carlmont student who has experienced a form of sexual assault, believes it’s hard for people to understand how harmful this song can be.

“If you don’t know about sexual assault or rape, and you haven’t experienced it, then you don’t know how it feels to be someone who does,” Russo said.

Sometimes it’s just easier to enjoy the Christmas spirit and hearty tone the song brings without paying much attention to the meaning of the song.

“People don’t really listen to lyrics anymore; they just listen to the music,” Hollier said.

This could be the reason for the results of the public poll KOIT held on their website. Despite the fact that they “received more complaints on the song than any other song ever played in the history of the radio station,” according to program director Brian Figula, the station ultimately decided to let the decision lie with the public.

After several days and hundreds of rampant emails and comments, the ballot results were released with a 90 percent vote in favor of bringing back the song.

With the song set to return to the cheery Christmas lovers’ playlists, the public is left to reflect on what this shows about society’s views of what is right and what is wrong.

“Different people view certain things as right and wrong. By banning the song, it shows that males can’t just be pushy and get everything they want,” Hollier said.

Although this is somewhat true, KOIT obviously didn’t change their morals suddenly.

When asked about the songs that are banned, Hollier said, “It’s just a way of trying to satisfy everyone’s needs.”

The same goes for its re-release on the station. Although a supporter of the women’s rights, KOIT has no personal involvement in the matter.

“In all honesty, I don’t think it was going to have that much of an effect,” Hollier said.

According to Russo, while the hopes of the people who wished the song to be banned were to “stir up something and make people more aware,” the banning held little hope for real change in society.

For the #MeToo movement to be on a path for greatness, it may take more than banning an old song from a different time to change the public’s view.

Banning one song from a radio may be ineffective while hundreds of other songs with similar messages are being played on other stations.

Hip-hop culture is a large influence on America’s youth to stop the spread of messages like the one in ‘Baby It’s Cold Outside.’

Hip-hop music, although deeply diverse and creative, frequently contains derogatory language and references.

“They’re basically describing the same message — they’re showing that males are supposed to be dominant over females. But because hip-hop and rap are popular right now, it’s harder to speak out against it,” Hollier said.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






2 Comments

2 Responses to “Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’”

  1. Sheila Ramirez on December 12th, 2018 5:32 pm

    https://g.co/kgs/Tz28yc

    Banning this song is insane to me. Yet they play this rap song regularly on mainstream radio. They bleep out the F and B word. However, the message is clear. It is a very popular song. Yet people can’t deal with “Baby it’s cold outside.”
    We are losing it and going backwards in America.
    Thank you for your time.

  2. Sheila Ramirez on December 12th, 2018 5:52 pm

    Great article by the way! I just don’t understand why we can’t discuss the offensive rap and hip hop songs. Yet we have to run to a “safe place” over Baby it’s cold outside! Ha ha I hope you see how crazy this is. I love rap and hip hop. As a 52 year old Parent of a Sophomore at Carlmont I enjoy all genres. If I don’t like the lyrics, then I don’t listen to it. I have a choice. That’s the beauty of it. Personal choice. I’m free to turn it off! I’m not falling Victim to a song from 1942. Can you believe this? I can think on my own! I’m not a victim over a song from 1942! Nor am I a victim to a hip hop song of 2018! Why? Because I’m free and I can make a choice not to listen! Wow what a concept! No victim mentality! Not being bullied by a song!! It’s a great feeling. Hoping some of these easily offended Students can free themselves from this Victim mentality. It’s so liberating.
    Thanks for reading my opinion. I appreciate your articles. Be free it’s yours! Cheers.

We invite comments and responses to our content. Comments will be published that are deemed appropriate and relevant.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    News

    Realities of unkept roads are driven over by society

  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    News

    ScotSkim: anticipation

  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    News

    Wildflower Walk provides a relaxing and informative hike

  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    News

    San Francisco salutes Irish heritage with annual parade

  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    News

    ScotSkim: challengers

  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    News

    The Turkic community bonds over Nowruz celebration

  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    News

    KonMari Method tidies up people’s lives

  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    News

    Skydiving leprechaun brings St. Patrick’s Day to Hiller Aviation Museum

  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    Features

    A light in the darkness: How different Carlmont students cope with struggles

  • Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’

    News

    New rotation of art exhibits bring vibrance to Redwood City with secret, empowering messages

Navigate Right

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.
Bay Area radio stations ban Christmas song after calling it ‘controversial’