Scot Scoop News

‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

Melissa+Benoist+stands+proudly++as+CBS%27s+Supergirl.
Back to Article
Back to Article

‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

Melissa Benoist stands proudly  as CBS's Supergirl.

Melissa Benoist stands proudly as CBS's Supergirl.

CBS

Melissa Benoist stands proudly as CBS's Supergirl.

CBS

CBS

Melissa Benoist stands proudly as CBS's Supergirl.

Chesirae Barbano, Staff Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






CBS’s “Supergirl” added to the ever-growing list of superhero adaptions on Oct. 26 but missed the mark as a solid and consistent superhero show.

Kara Zor-El (played by Melissa Benoist) arrived on Earth as the 13-year-old cousin to Superman. She was adopted into a human family and grew up in a mostly human way. CBS tried to make it clear that this show was about Supergirl by focusing minimal attention on Superman.

As if she wasn’t similar enough to Clark Kent, the writers gave her glasses so she could rip them off dramatically as she changed into her alter ego, Supergirl. Despite the writers’ attempt to move away from Superman, Kara appeared as a female Clark Kent with her job, her glasses, and her demeanor.

By the time CBS stopped explaining her backstory, Kara had landed herself a job under a stereotypical diva. She fetched coffee and was the nerdy walking-mat for her boss, Cat Grant (played by Calista Flockhart).

Not only did she lack mental awareness for serious occurrences when she fought crime, but acted like a child when situations didn’t go her way. Kara resorted to storming off-scene when she and her sister (played by Chyler Leigh) clashed.

When she decided to embrace her Kryptonian powers, she had zero sense of secrecy. After taking the media by storm, Kara felt little support and revealed her powers to her colleague, Winslow Schott Jr. (played by Jeremy Jordon).

Like most superhero renditions, the creators ignored the physical capabilities of a Kryptonian to progress the plot. Although Kara’s senses exceeded that of a human’s, her powers were not always exploited. In one instance, she heard her boss’ snide comments in an elevator, but in another, failed to see incoming projectiles.

With so many discrepancies in the characters and the plot, CBS’s attempt to join the comic book bandwagon crashed and burned, just like Krypton.

Why watch CBS’s “Supergirl” (2015) when viewers could watch the same plot with “Superman” (1951)?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






About the Writer
Chesirae Barbano, Staff Writer

Junior Chesirae Barbano signed up for journalism without knowing what she was getting herself into. Humor is her favorite song, along with the clicks...

Leave a Comment

We invite comments and responses to our content. Comments will be published that are deemed appropriate and relevant.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    Carlmont Choir’s ‘American Songbook’ is a joyous success

  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    ‘Alien: Covenant’ is barely tolerable

  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    Juicy barbecue served in the smokeless Bay Area

  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    Kabul Afghan Cuisine serves up amazing and rich platters

  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    ‘Fifty Shades Darker’ outplayed by its soundtrack

  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    San Carlos Bar and Grill serves up amazing seafood

  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    Waterdog Tavern: something familiar, something different

  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    Blue Line Pizza serves simply exquisite dishes

  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    ‘Lady Wood’ nearly hits the bird’s eye

  • ‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super

    A&E

    Asian fusion and ice cream tacos served on the street

Navigate Right

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.
‘Supergirl’ isn’t so super