Scot Scoop News

Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

A silhouette of a singer.

A silhouette of a singer.

Dominic Gialdini, Highlander Entertainment Editor

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






[clip art by Meri Knight] A silhouette of a singer.

“American Idol,” once the most-watched television show in the United States, continued its downward spiral when, on the first episode of Season 12, its viewers reached an all-time low for a premiere.

According to CNN, on Wed., Jan. 16, Fox’s reality show attracted the attention of a mere 17.9 million viewers, 19 percent less than the previous season’s premiere.

“I’m not that interested in watching ‘American Idol.’ I would rather watch ‘The X-Factor because Simon [Cowell] is on it,” said Mackenna Galicia, a sophomore.

“American Idol” steadily lost much of its fan base after Paula Abdul and Simon Cowell, two of the three original judges, left the show after Season Eight and Season Nine, respectively. Ever since then, Americans have lost their emotional investment in the judges.

“‘American Idol’ has not been the same since Simon left,” stated sophomore Emily Costello.

This year, “American Idol” introduced three new judges to the panel; Keith Urban, Mariah Carey, and Nicki Minaj. Many Carlmont students refused to watch the show because of their opposition to these new judges.

“I will not watch the show because it gets worse every year. It is the judges’ faults for that,” exclaimed sophomore Madeline McGee.

Minaj, in particular, fell under Carlmont scrutiny. Students did not believe that she was qualified to be chosen as a judge in the first place.

“Who in their right mind puts Nicki Minaj as an authority figure in anything remotely influential to viewers,” questioned sophomore Tina Enkhbat.

Minaj, a popular rapper and singer with an outlandish personality and style, has a tendency to get on people’s nerves. This contributed to the lack of viewers that “American Idol” generated on its premiere.

Sophomore Amanda Breslauer said, “I’m not going to watch ‘American Idol’ anymore because I don’t like Nicki Minaj.”

The future of “American Idol” looks bleak. If the show does not find a way to make the judges appeal to the viewers, it may not have many seasons left.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






About the Writer
Dominic Gialdini, Highlander Editor

Dominic Gialdini is the features editor for the Carlmont Highlander. In addition to editing, he is a columnist for the Highlander and an intern at the...

Leave a Comment

Comments are closed.

Navigate Left
  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    Carlmont Choir’s ‘American Songbook’ is a joyous success

  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    ‘Alien: Covenant’ is barely tolerable

  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    Juicy barbecue served in the smokeless Bay Area

  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    Kabul Afghan Cuisine serves up amazing and rich platters

  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    ‘Fifty Shades Darker’ outplayed by its soundtrack

  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    San Carlos Bar and Grill serves up amazing seafood

  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    Waterdog Tavern: something familiar, something different

  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    Blue Line Pizza serves simply exquisite dishes

  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    ‘Lady Wood’ nearly hits the bird’s eye

  • Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”

    A&E

    Asian fusion and ice cream tacos served on the street

Navigate Right

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.
Judges digging a grave for “American Idol”