The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.

Scot Scoop News

The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.

Scot Scoop News

The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.

Scot Scoop News

Private schools vs. Public schools: Bay Area edition

Many factors determine the quality of Bay Area schooling
Maya Benjamin
Leslie McPherson looks at school options for children in the area of Redwood Shores.


Almost a half million public school students enrolled in the ninth grade in California in the fall of 2015.

Leah Auyoung was one of them.

After attending private schools her whole life, Auyoung decided to look at a public high school.

“The community love stood out to me at Carlmont along with the spirit,” she said.

Auyoung saw Carlmont as an outstanding public school in her area.

The high level of public school options in the Bay Area attracted Auyong as well as Leslie and Glenn McPherson.

Sandpiper Elementary School in Redwood Shores and Carlmont High School in the neighboring city of Belmont both had a score of 1000 on the Academic Performance Index during the early 2000s.

The Academic Performance Index is a measurement of individual schools academic performance in California.

Schools can score from a low of 200 to a high of 1000.

Leslie and Glenn McPherson were impressed and moved to Redwood Shores immediately.

Leslie McPherson said, “We moved to Redwood Shores solely based on the schools this area had available.”

Leslie McPherson’s eldest daughter Logan McPherson did not enjoy her experience at Ralston, a Belmont middle school, and the McPhersons considered a private high school. Logan Mcpherson felt Ralston hadn’t given her enough structure for her to be successful.

However, after touring Carlmont High School, the McPhersons decided Carlmont was the best school for them.

“There’s nothing that an independent school offered that Carlmont doesn’t,” Leslie said.

The McPhersons also felt that public schools in the Bay Area offered a good education for no cost, a lot of diversity, and a community-oriented feel.

As a mother of both a Catholic and public school student, Carol Lynd feels the same way. After attending Catholic school her entire life, Lynd decided to do the same for her two children.

Lynd prefers the more hands-on approach at private schools for lower grades, but she believes that a public high school offers an independent approach to learning that can help students for college and beyond.

While there are many differences between public schools and private schools, there are also many similarities. Lynd feels that both independent and public schools in the Bay Area offer a high level of teachers.

“I felt the level of teachers at both independent and public schools were very high,” said Lynd.

For some, private schools are more beneficial because of their small class sizes.

Skyler Ross, a sophomore at the Urban School of San Francisco, said, “In an independent school the classes are smaller so it’s easier to identify my strengths and weaknesses in a class.”

Ross said she never considered a public school option for high school because of the poor reputation public schools have in San Francisco.

Ross said, “In independent schools, there’s a rumor that academics aren’t taken seriously in public schools.”

This reputation has led many families to look at private school options in San Francisco.

The reputation public schools in San Francisco have is different from the Peninsula where most families have embraced their good public schools.

Despite this, seven out of 10 counties in the Bay Area have 10 percent or more of their students enrolled in an independent or Catholic school.

According to Niche, a website made for discovering the best schools for parents and children in the area, private schools have 11 schools from the Bay Area ranked on the 2017 best independent schools in America list while public schools only have three schools ranked on the 2017 best public high schools in America.

Niche compiled their ranking from a rigorous analysis of data from the U.S. Department of Education, along with test scores, college data, and ratings from millions of Niche users.

Parents look for a wide variety of things when choosing a school for their children.The environment, facility, teacher quality, and academic performance of the school are just some examples.

Whether public or private, most people wants a school they feel most comfortable at. 

Navigate Left
Navigate Right
About the Contributor
Maya Benjamin
Maya Benjamin, Staff Writer
Maya Benjamin is a senior at Carlmont High School. Maya has been apart of journalism for three years and is very grateful for the privilege of being able to write for such amazing publications. Maya enjoys listening to music and singing in her free time.

Comments (0)

We invite comments and responses to our content. Comments that are deemed appropriate and relevant will be published.
All Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Activate Search
The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.
Private schools vs. Public schools: Bay Area edition