The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.

Scot Scoop News

The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.

Scot Scoop News

The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.

Scot Scoop News

Educational experience determines political beliefs

Emma Romanowsky
Many graduates have liberal political viewpoints.

The United States of America is rarely united.

For much of America’s history, its political climate has been divided. And, according to Pew Research Center, the political gap in the United States is widening.  

Environmental factors play a key role in shaping the beliefs that pull Americans apart.

Education seems to be a major influence. Pew Research Center classifies a Liberal as a person who is “highly educated and financially stable” and Conservatives as “less educated and in favor of economic fairness.”

Gaby Pierce is a sophomore at Carlmont who moved to California in 2017 after growing up in Little Rock, Ark.. She reflected upon her educational experiences in Arkansas.

“In the south, a lot fewer people are college educated,” Pierce said. “The education system is so terrible there. I think if more people went to college, the schools would be better.”

Pew Research Center found that college-educated individuals most often vote liberally. However, according to the Washington Post, over 60 percent of Americans lack a bachelor’s degree.

Another factor that contributes to one’s beliefs is childhood environment.

Shelby Weiss, a senior from Jacksonville, Fla., and a self-identified Republican, believes that children are raised to have certain political viewpoints.

“I think family and where people grow up are the biggest influences on personal beliefs,” Weiss said. “When a child has the skills and education to formulate their own beliefs, they are already corrupted by the bias of others around them.”

Ayan Dixit, who is a sophomore and member of Carlmont’s Democrat club, said,  “I think family is a huge factor. All of my friends tend to stay with the same affiliation of their parents.”

An NPR article says that families tend to live in areas with similar political viewpoints.

Ryan Versen, who is the Vice President of the Conservative Thinkers club at Carlmont, spoke about conservative beliefs.

“A conservative thinker is pro-First Amendment. Even if we don’t believe someone’s views, we give them the chance to speak their mind,“ Versen said. “We may be pro-life in terms of abortion or maybe for the Second Amendment, but we believe that heavy tax cuts are the key to a strong economy.”

As Dixit discussed liberal ideologies, he said, “Democrats think that a larger government can be used as a tool to support everyone in our country and those who want to join.”

This separation in viewpoints could account for the difference of information received in the United States. Children are often taught different material based on whether they live in a conservative or liberal region.

The textbooks at public schools in Texas, a consistently Republican state, omit information about evolution and the civil war.

NPR reported on the Texas Board of Education’s conservative learning standards: “The books downplay some issues- like slavery- and skirt others- like Jim Crow laws. It’s definitely an attempt to whitewash our history as opposed to exposing students to the reality of things.”

The reality of things is that educational standards vary among states. A freshman biology class at schools like Carlmont in California has a unit dedicated to the Theory of Evolution while freshman biology in Texas does not cover the topic.

“Now that I think about it, I haven’t learned that much about evolution,” said Ashley Aronson, a junior at J.J. Pearce public high school in Dallas. “It’s not that it was ever denied, it was just never discussed.”

The inconsistency of nationwide learning standards could become more prominent.

The Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos is an “advocate for School Choice,” the ability to seek alternative options to public school like private or charter schools.

The most prominent of public school alternatives is a private school. Many in the United States who can afford it opt to attend private school.

“If you live in an area that doesn’t have a great public school and you have the money, normally you go to a private school,” Aronson said.

Still, there are many children who are unable to afford private education.

The Republican tax plan originally proposed in November 2017 set forth to further reduce public school spending.

Children who are unable to attend a better-funded school often lack the means to attend college.

According to Pew Research Center, college attendance rates amongst low-income (bottom 20 percent of household income) students are 30 percent lower than that of higher income (top 20 percent of household income) students.

People who lack higher education tend to vote conservatively.

Business Insider found that people with only a high school diploma favored Donald Trump 51 percent to Hillary Clinton’s 45 percent while postcollege graduates favored Hillary Clinton 58 percent to 37 percent.  

In the 2017 Alabama Senate election, Roy Moore, the Conservative candidate, received far more votes from non-college educated individuals than he did from college graduates.

While formal education has an influence on political perspectives, informal education through information provided by the internet also seems to impact one’s positions.

Online platforms such as Google and Facebook, are known for displaying information based on a person’s web history and geographic location. A person in one state can visit the same platform as a person living in a different state, and they can see different homepages.

In a TED talk, Eli Pariser, author of “The Filter Bubble,” spoke about the filtration of information coming from online sources.

“The internet shows us what we want to see,” said Pariser. “It’s not necessarily what we need to see, and we don’t get to see what gets filtered out.”

This difference in received information furthers the gap between Liberals and Conservatives because they receive entirely different versions of an event without ever seeing the other side.

People really do read alternative facts.

Pariser saw this when he asked friends of his to type the same keyword into Google and to send him screenshots of their results.

“I asked my friends to Google ‘Egypt’ and send me what they got,” said Pariser. “When I put them side by side, I didn’t even have to read the links to see how different the pages were.”

Information discrepancy seems to be the driving factor between Democrats and Republicans. A child born into a liberal family will likely receive a liberal education from their environment and likewise for a child born into a conservative family.

Because some regions in the United States overwhelmingly favor one party over the other, it can be difficult to live in those regions and have opposite beliefs.

In Arkansas, Pierce found herself being a liberal minority.

“My friend and I were the only people in my grade that had come out as openly liberal. Everyone else wanted Donald Trump to win,” Pierce said.

Likewise, Versen described the challenges of being a conservative in liberal Silicon Valley.

“It’s hard to speak your mind without being called a Nazi, racist, homophobe, xenophobe, or transphobe,” Versen said. “Just because I have different ideas, everyone thinks I’m the bad guy.”

Perhaps one day, America as a society will overcome the political divisions that drive many of its citizens apart.

“Everybody makes assumptions about what the other person believes in, and often these assumptions are not true,” Pierce said. “I think when we stop making assumptions and just understand perspectives from both sides, we can actually find common ground in our country.”

Navigate Left
Navigate Right
About the Contributor
Emma Romanowsky
Emma Romanowsky, Highlander Editor-in-Chief
Emma Romanowsky is a senior at Carlmont High School. This is her third year of being on the journalism staff and she is the Editor-in-Chief of Highlander newsmagazine. She loves using journalism to spark conversation about controversial subjects. To check out her portfolio, click here. Twitter: @ERomanowsky

Comments (0)

We invite comments and responses to our content. Comments that are deemed appropriate and relevant will be published.
All Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Activate Search
The student news site of Carlmont High School in Belmont, California.
Educational experience determines political beliefs